Fact check: Vice President JD Vance Delivers Remarks in Middletown, OH
JD Vance · August 21, 2026 · 46 min
Every claim, in order
- MOSTLY TRUEat 29:27
“At the end of World War two, The United States produced almost 70% of total global steel production.”
What the data shows: In 1945, the US produced 72% of the world's steel according to Wikipedia's History of the Iron and Steel Industry in the United States. Other sources cite 'over 60%' or 'more than half' for the late 1940s period.
- MOSTLY TRUEat 30:18
“Our steel industry declined to only 5% of global steel production.”
What the data shows: U.S. produced 82 million metric tons of crude steel in 2025 out of 1,849.4 million metric tons global production, representing 4.4% of global output (World Steel Association, January 2026).
- MOSTLY TRUEat 30:18
“The United States oil production peaked in 1971. It declined for thirty five years.”
What the data shows: U.S. crude oil production peaked in 1970 at ~9.6 million barrels/day (EIA). Production declined through the mid-2000s, reaching a low ~5 million bbl/day around 2008—approximately 38 years, not 35. The speaker's timeframe is slightly compressed but directionally accurate.
- TRUEat 31:04
“we're by far the world's largest producer of oil”
What the data shows: As of 2024, the U.S. is the world's largest crude oil producer at ~13.3 million barrels per day, ahead of Saudi Arabia and Russia (EIA, Petroleum & Other Liquids, Monthly Data, Jan 2025).
- MOSTLY TRUEat 31:04
“we're the largest net exporter of oil and natural gas on planet Earth”
What the data shows: U.S. is a net exporter of both crude oil and natural gas as of 2024. However, 'largest net exporter' of both combined is not definitively established in a single metric; the U.S. leads in LNG exports and crude exports separately (EIA, Trade Data, 2024).
- MISLEADINGat 32:35
“our Department of Energy's partnership with this fantastic company, Cleveland Cliffs, to invest a billion dollars”
What the data shows: DOE awarded $500 million; total project cost is $1 billion with Cleveland Cliffs contributing $500 million (announced Aug 21, 2026).
- MOSTLY TRUEat 43:44
“economists have measured the ways in which the opioid crisis exploded in the very locations where jobs were shipped overseas”
What the data shows: Peer-reviewed study (Dean & Kimmel, 2019) found trade-related job losses associated with 2.7% increase in opioid deaths per 1,000 jobs lost; 11.3% when fentanyl present. Study used CDC and DOL county-level data, 1999–2015.
- FALSEat 46:54· said in 3 broadcasts
“We created more than twenty twenty nine thousand new jobs in the sector in 2026 so far.”
What the data shows: BLS monthly data shows approximately 42,000 manufacturing jobs added January-July 2026; White House cited 18,000 through early August 2026.
- FALSEat 46:54· said in 2 broadcasts
“year over year, manufacturing workers wages actually went up. 4.2% where they went down under the Biden administration”
What the data shows: 1.4% — Real Wages (YoY) for Trump II at month 8 of the term (~2025), per FRED.
- TRUEat 46:54
“imports for capital goods are reaching historic peaks”
What the data shows: US capital goods imports reached $128.0 billion in May 2026, a record high per Commerce Department data. Prior all-time high was approximately $78.1 billion in March 2022.
- MISLEADINGat 46:54· said in 2 broadcasts
“Demand for metal cutting. And similar machine tools is hitting its highest levels in a century in The United States Of America.”
What the data shows: AMT reports H1 2026 metal cutting/forming machine orders reached $3.4 billion, the strongest half-year since USMTO data collection began in 1998. No dataset tracks demand over a full century.
- MISLEADINGat 47:50
“Cleveland Cliffs is making today right here in Middletown, Ohio, a $1,000,000,000 investment in transformational manufacturing”
What the data shows: Cleveland Cliffs is contributing $500 million; DOE grant is $500 million; combined total is $1 billion. Announced August 21, 2026.
- TRUEat 48:36
“Cleveland Cliffs is making today right here in Middletown, Ohio, a $1,000,000,000 investment in transformational manufacturing”
What the data shows: Cleveland-Cliffs and the U.S. Department of Energy announced a combined $1 billion investment on August 21, 2026: $500 million federal grant plus $500 million from Cleveland-Cliffs. The company's total net capital outlay is $1.3 billion over 5 years (2025-2029).
- FALSEat 51:45
“America saw net migration out of the country as we sent millions of illegal immigrants back home”
What the data shows: Census Bureau reports net international migration of 1.3 million (July 2024–June 2025), positive not negative. DHS reports ~605,000 deportations since Jan 20, 2025; independent trackers show ~290,000 formal removals. No source documents 'millions' of deportations.
- MISLEADINGat 51:45
“all net job growth”
What the data shows: BLS data shows native-born employment increased and foreign-born employment decreased in Trump's second term (Jan-Nov 2025), but economists note these figures are statistical artifacts from Census Bureau population estimates made in 2024, not evidence of actual job displacement.
- MISLEADINGat 52:31· said in 3 broadcasts
“under Joe Biden, the cost of a median price home nearly doubled”
What the data shows: Median home price (FRED MSPUS): Jan 2021 ~$355K → Jan 2025 ~$420K = ~18% increase, not doubling. If comparing to pandemic low (Apr 2020 ~$305K), increase is ~38%.
- MOSTLY TRUEat 52:31
“for the first time in over five years, rents are falling”
What the data shows: 2.7% — Inflation (CPI) in 2025 (Biden), per BLS CPI-U.
- MOSTLY TRUEat 53:18· said in 8 broadcasts
“the largest reduction in violent crime in the history of our country”
What the data shows: FBI reports 9.3% violent crime decline 2024-2025, largest year-to-year drop since 1936. Murder rate tied with 1955-1956 for lowest on record. Pre-1936 data unavailable.
- MISLEADINGat 53:18· said in 2 broadcasts
“homicides are at their lowest level in our country, the lowest level in a hundred and twenty six years”
What the data shows: FBI reports 2025 homicide rate tied with 1955–1956 as lowest since 1900. 2024 rate was lowest since at least 1969. FBI data does not reliably extend to 1898.
- MISLEADINGat 55:36
“the inflation that was brought on by Joe Biden underinvesting and trying to destroy American industry”
What the data shows: 6.4% — Inflation (CPI) in 2022 (Biden), per BLS CPI-U.
More: Vice President JD Vance Delivers Remarks in Brewer, ME · President Trump Greets Lifeguard Ryder Williams